chinshentw wrote:
之後就不再佔版面了, 自己搜尋吧, 別再把WIKI的東西當作寶了 ...(恕刪)


那請問那個WIKI上比薩斜塔的條目有哪是寫錯的?
歡迎您去斧正喔,
不過最好是有可考據的參考文獻.且WIKI上不接受個人原創性研究(也就是個人論點).
chinshentw wrote:
看一下#165的post吧, 貼這篇只是要讓您認識一下Karl Terzaghi, 因為想來您一點概念也沒有 ...(恕刪)


既然有你說的那麽多文章,你就找幾篇完全跟你說法(這麼多年了, 大家還是記得他老兄的錯誤設計)一模一樣的SCI文章來給大家看吧..
大家等著!

既然你很有概念你就講清楚說明白嘛!
如果有錯誤, 是錯誤在哪? 是怎樣的錯誤法, 多幾個字能讓所有人都看明白不會誤解
這樣不是比較好嗎?

fisheriestw wrote:
用不著抬槓吧.我更用...(恕刪)


所以我說您外行就是這樣, 您舉SCI這種涵蓋率這麼廣的範圍所以多少有機會沾到邊就是了.

我建議您這種程度不適合來跟我叫陣, 跟您在這種您不懂的專業上糾纏, 修理也算是勝之不武.


不過我想您還是誤解WIKI上的解釋, 如果WIKI的中文您會曲解, 我想非本業的期刊對您太難了
fisheriestw wrote:
既然有你說的那麽多,...(恕刪)


http://precast.org/precast-magazines/precast-solutions/2012-spring/geotechnical-soils-engineering-a-solid-foundation/

Leaning Tower of Pisa: something is up

Several foundation-related engineering problems, like the differential settlement of Italy’s Leaning Tower of Pisa, prompted a more scientific approach to examining the subsurface. The earliest documented advances in soil mechanics occurred in 1717 when Henri Gautier developed earth pressure theories for the construction of the retaining wall. Since then, there have been significant advancements in the science and engineering behind soil mechanics. In 1925, there was major progress with the publication of Erdbaumechanik by Karl Terzaghi (considered to be the father of modern soil mechanics and geotechnical engineering). Terzaghi developed the principle of effective stress, demonstrated that sheer strength of soil is controlled by this effective stress, and created the theories of foundation-bearing capacity and the rate of settlement due to consolidation.

Structural performance depends on firm footing
Today’s geotechnical engineers perform investigations to obtain information on the physical properties of soil and rock underlying (and adjacent to) a site and use this data to design earthworks and foundations for proposed structures. Geotechnical investigations include surface and sub-surface explorations to ensure that the proposed building site’s soils and/or bedrock are suitable for placement of precast concrete structures.

Proper installation of precast concrete products is critical for maintaining structural integrity. The modular nature and simple joint connections of precast concrete components enable fast assembly. Proper installation once on site ensures structural performance while maintaining a safe work environment.

Precast concrete products differentiate themselves from alternative products in that the load-carrying capacity of precast concrete is derived from its own structural integrity, not from the adjacent soil or consolidated backfill. A precast concrete product can be designed as a separately engineered unit or system to withstand all loading conditions, unlike other products that must rely on adjacent soils to meet specified in-service strengths.

Subgrade soil conditions will affect the overall performance of any bearing structure, therefore it is important that precasters adhere to local and industry-wide standards, codes and best practices when dealing with the actual design, site preparation and installation of precast concrete products. Producers can also assist the owner, contractor and inspectors through organized and accurate scheduling of materials, construction procedures, contract documents, plans and specifications.

隨意節錄一段, 大家都知道比薩斜塔的問題是不均勻沉陷, 但Structural performance depends on firm footing, 那是有救的, 只是原設計者不懂, 還有網友硬凹就是

chinshentw wrote:
所以我說您外行就是這樣, 您舉SCI這種涵蓋率這麼廣的範圍所以多少有機會沾到邊就是了.

我建議您這種程度不適合來跟我叫陣, 跟您在這種您不懂的專業上糾纏, 修理也算是勝之不武.


不過我想您還是誤解WIKI上的解釋, 如果WIKI的中文您會曲解, 我想非本業的期刊對您太難了...(恕刪)


我有說過我很內行嗎?
我有必要跟你叫陣嗎?
你把我當敵人啊?
您搞錯了吧?!?

講SCI論文不過是個科學,工程普遍公信力的標準.
你要更嚴格當然也可以..

WIKI上有哪段陳述說到比薩斜塔是如你所說錯誤的設計?
你寧可寫一堆543的也不願舉任何一篇符合你說法的參考文獻豈不奇怪?
chinshentw wrote:
http://precast.org/precast-magazines/precast-solutions/2012-spring/geotechnical-soils-engineering-a-solid-foundation/

Leaning Tower of Pisa: something is up

Several foundation-related engineering problems, like the differential settlement of Italy’s Leaning Tower of Pisa, prompted a more scientific approach to examining the subsurface. The earliest documented advances in soil mechanics occurred in 1717 when Henri Gautier developed earth pressure theories for the construction of the retaining wall. Since then, there have been significant advancements in the science and engineering behind soil mechanics. In 1925, there was major progress with the publication of Erdbaumechanik by Karl Terzaghi (considered to be the father of modern soil mechanics and geotechnical engineering). Terzaghi developed the principle of effective stress, demonstrated that sheer strength of soil is controlled by this effective stress, and created the theories of foundation-bearing capacity and the rate of settlement due to consolidation.

Structural performance depends on firm footing
Today’s geotechnical engineers perform investigations to obtain information on the physical properties of soil and rock underlying (and adjacent to) a site and use this data to design earthworks and foundations for proposed structures. Geotechnical investigations include surface and sub-surface explorations to ensure that the proposed building site’s soils and/or bedrock are suitable for placement of precast concrete structures.

Proper installation of precast concrete products is critical for maintaining structural integrity. The modular nature and simple joint connections of precast concrete components enable fast assembly. Proper installation once on site ensures structural performance while maintaining a safe work environment.

Precast concrete products differentiate themselves from alternative products in that the load-carrying capacity of precast concrete is derived from its own structural integrity, not from the adjacent soil or consolidated backfill. A precast concrete product can be designed as a separately engineered unit or system to withstand all loading conditions, unlike other products that must rely on adjacent soils to meet specified in-service strengths.

Subgrade soil conditions will affect the overall performance of any bearing structure, therefore it is important that precasters adhere to local and industry-wide standards, codes and best practices when dealing with the actual design, site preparation and installation of precast concrete products. Producers can also assist the owner, contractor and inspectors through organized and accurate scheduling of materials, construction procedures, contract documents, plans and specifications.

隨意節錄一段, 大家都知道比薩斜塔的問題是不均勻沉陷, 但Structural performance depends on firm footing, 那是有救的, 只是原設計者不懂, 還有網友硬凹就是...(恕刪)


你引這篇文章中哪有哪個你講的"這麼多年了, 大家還是記得他老兄的錯誤設計"????

且何以知道原設計者原本就知道該地質狀況與特性?

fisheriestw wrote:
我有說過我很內行嗎?...(恕刪)


參照一下#175吧, 麻煩您用Karl Terzaghi, leaning tower of pisa當關鍵字查一下
chinshentw wrote:
參照一下#175吧, 麻煩您用Karl Terzaghi, leaning tower of pisa當關鍵字查一下...(恕刪)


你既是相當在行, 很有概念那你查給大家看何難之有?
但#175跟你的"這麼多年了, 大家還是記得他老兄的錯誤設計"說法不符喔..

fisheriestw wrote:
你引這篇文章中哪有哪...(恕刪)


因為比薩斜塔就真的是錯誤設計阿, WIKI上說的是沒打算蓋成斜的,
但的確是斜的阿, 這樣到底還算不算是錯誤設計
chinshentw wrote:
因為比薩斜塔就真的是錯誤設計阿, WIKI上說的是沒打算蓋成斜的,
但的確是斜的阿, 這樣到底還算不算是錯誤設計 ...(恕刪)


造成傾斜的問題在於地質, 但能不能說設計者"錯誤設計"得考慮以下基本邏輯問題.
1.設計者明確知道施工地的地質狀況.
2.在1.確定存在下設計者還做此設計.
3.確定設計者原預定的施工地就是現址.
4.其他,如施工完全按原設計要求無變更等.
這幾點皆確定存在下才能說設計者是"錯誤設計"吧.
這幾點可有確定了嗎?

有哪篇文章確定了這幾點皆為確定存在?
文章分享
評分
評分
複製連結
請輸入您要前往的頁數(1 ~ 23)

今日熱門文章 網友點擊推薦!