小弟才疏學淺 望各位大德幫忙釐清思緒

juneblue1977 wrote:
h先生就是老鷹大~主(恕刪)


我在另外一棟邀約他過來直接聊聊天 他也不來
lion2414 wrote:
就這位偉大的思想家 老鷹哥所言

1. 美國承認中國的立場,即只有一中,臺灣屬中
2. 美國承認美國的立場,即只有一中,臺灣屬中

請問這兩件事該如何解釋

就實質上兩個中國,或是一中一台
中國當然就不容模糊
搞模糊的是美國

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Policy_of_deliberate_ambiguity#Taiwan

美國對台用的是《台灣關係法》和《六項保證》
中國跟美國用的是三個聯合公報,這樣懂了吧?

就像民進黨去中國做生意就不會講政治,回來台灣也不會宣傳祖國好先進,好發達,台灣必須要統一
這樣很難懂嗎?
mindcry wrote:
就實質上兩個中國,或(恕刪)


我不反對你的立場 你這麼解讀美國對兩岸的認知是你的看法 闡述自己的看法是無庸置疑的

但是對偉大的思想家---老鷹哥

他都用一些似是而非的邏輯去闡述一些他自己的想法

誠如你的回文

美國對台用的是《台灣關係法》和《六項保證》
中國跟美國用的是三個聯合公報


這個是合理的 也有根有據

但是偉大的思想家---老鷹哥

美國承認中國的立場,即只有一中,臺灣屬中
美國承認美國的立場,即只有一中,臺灣屬中


這些我就不能認同 完全只是詭辯
lion2414 wrote:
美國承認美國的立場,即只有一中,臺灣屬中

這一句我也看不懂,反正美國有自己的利益,立場可以隨時更改
這就叫作戰略模糊

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Policy_of_deliberate_ambiguity#Taiwan

MR. RYAN: This questioner would like to know, you have just returned from a visit to China and Taiwan, and wants to know, do you think the United States should be prepared to defend Taiwan if they are attacked by China, as President Bush sort of led people to believe not long ago?

SEN. BIDEN: President Bush did say that, and then he got it right. I mean, he said it, exactly what seven other presidents have said. This is what you might call studied ambiguity, and that's exactly what it should be. Let me tell you why it should be, why it should be. We signed, under Richard Nixon, a new agreement. We did away with the Taiwan Defense Act and replaced it with the Taiwan Relations Act. And that act said the following. It said that we support a One-China policy, but it rests upon a cross-strait dialogue where the countries, where the parties, mutually arrive at how unification will take place peacefully; that if the mainland attempts to do this by force and not dialogue, then the United States will provide the military means in terms of materiel to prevent that from happening. Mainland China has no capacity, no capacity to occupy Taiwan today. They could not lift 50,000 troops across the straits, let alone 500,000 troops across the straits. But there's a second piece of this equation. The second piece of the equation is we also said to Taiwan, "You are no longer an independent country. You are no longer an independent nation-state. We've agreed that you are going to be part of China and that you will work it out under what conditions. So don't go declaring independence, because we are not willing to go to war over your unilateral declaration of independence," which leaves unanswered, as it should be, so we don't encourage reckless action on either side, that depending on how each of the parties behave, we reserve the right, as we do in every circumstance, to use American forces. It will depend upon the circumstances. That's how it's been for seven presidents. That's how it should remain.

https://www.c-span.org/video/?165936-1/us-foreign-policy&start=2968
mindcry wrote:
這一句我也看不懂,反(恕刪)


是呀 個人淺見 言論自由應該建立在正常的邏輯觀念上

例如你的回文 最少有根有據 最少公平地闡述兩邊的論點

再說一次 偉大的思想家---老鷹哥

只是單純的詭辯 找一些單方面的文章資料 進行無謂的邏輯觀念

跟他不是同路人的 就巴不得把人打進跟中國同一路 就是要賣台

我想討論的是這樣的雙標
文章分享
評分
評分
複製連結

今日熱門文章 網友點擊推薦!