[求救]請問wifi 電波太強,如何阻擋?


天線轉個方向就好

射向靠外面的水泥牆即可

打去給鄰居用啦
不排除有人可能對電磁波會有感覺,但是這樣的人是不可能過正常的生活,如果你日常生活都不會暈,那只能說一切只是心理因素,因為現在很多人都會埋AP,尤其是一些店家,埋的比你腳下那台強多了,說不定你工作或上學的頭上就有一個,走進超商,頭上一定有一個。走在路上不會暈?天上的衛星通訊、GPS、電台等等都在對著你打,旁邊開過去的計程車、卡車,車上的火腿正在對著你打,這東西可是比你腳下的WIFI強多了,你感覺到了嗎?還有一個你沒感覺的手機基地台,說不定正在你樓上,他比WIFI強N倍,另有一個你不知道的,手機微型基地台、強波器,說不定正在你身邊或隔壁,這東西也是比WIFI強多了。座車時,很多人都在那滑,你沒感覺?那可是比你腳下的強N倍。
回覆上面網友建議:
1) 鋁箔包把天線蓋起來就好了啦
測試過了,不行

2) 我的機器型號是edimax br-6228ns

3) 關於Wifi訊號對人體有沒有害,以及那麼多基地台、手機訊號等等問題,並不是如同各位網友所說那樣可以直接類推比較的。(歡迎大家認真討論,口水閒話就免了)

我查了以下幾篇研究:
a) UK Power Watch:
http://www.powerwatch.org.uk/rf/wifi.asp
b) 2007/12 Updated Memorandum on WiFi Research
http://www.powerwatch.org.uk/pdfs/20080425_wifi_memorandum.pdf

幾個摘要如下:

a. There has been plenty of media coverage of WiFi and the potential dangers in 2007. There is a lot of misunderstanding and misrepresentation of evidence being thrown into the mix, and it is becoming very hard to follow the strands of a) what the exposure levels are, b) what the evidence is actually saying, and c) what other aspects need to be considered on WiFi.

b. Last in 2008 a new website(http://www.wifiinschools.org.uk/) appeared providing a rational and well supported scientific argument for the validity in precaution of the use of WiFi in primary and secondary schools.

c. Therefore 20 minutes on a mobile phone running at typical power levels would be equivalent to about 16 hours in a classroom with 20 wLAN PCs, approximately eight standard school days.

d. However, these figures are assuming that it is cumulative absorbed power that is being implicated in RF research, and that then implies a linear dose-response relationship model. From the evidence that has found a risk, this seems unlikely to be the case. Peak signal strength received may also be important, and people using WiFi enabled laptops would regularly be exposed to electric fields of 2 to 3 V/m. Whilst this is far below ICNIRP, it is far above the levels where adverse health effects are being reported (~0.05 V/m).(這段我看不太懂)

e.Firstly, typical exposure from a phone in use is likely to be far higher than from a typical WiFi laptop or access point due to the different in proximity to the device in question. So whilst, again, there is research showing that there may be a risk, this may not be relevant.

f. To study secondary school children in the 12 -15 year-old age-range as we have reports that this group is more affected than primary school children . This may be due to their long
er exposure to environmental agents.

另外,根據 http://wifiinschools.org.uk/22.html裡有提到,Papers finding biological or adverse health effects of Wi-Fi signals, Wi-Fi-enabled devices or Wi-Fi frequencies (2.4 or 5 GHz).

我無電子相關背景,看上述文章也是大半看不懂,因此只摘要英文,不敢隨便翻譯。歡迎高手協助釐清。謝謝~



irischennet wrote:
很認真地請問一下大家...(恕刪)


Wifi-AP裝到客廳就好了

不過你在書桌上頭暈
怎麼想都不覺得是Wifi-AP引起的

irischennet wrote:
我家的Wifi AP剛好裝在書桌下方,


不是搞笑,既然體質這麼敏感,拔AP電源不就得了?(不是就在腳下?)

irischennet wrote:
回覆上面網友建議:1...(恕刪)


到底會不會有影響看那些論文也不會有解,因為你懷疑你屬於較敏感族群不是?
那看對一般大眾到底有沒有影響的文章意義不大

要證明你是不是真的有被影響那也很簡單嘛,找你家人用布矇住你的眼睛,隨機開關你的wifi AP,然後讓你猜你的wifi AP目前到底是屬於開還關的狀態,要求不多,你能猜十次中十次不就證明你真的是因為它才感到不適的了?


這可不是在為難,我如果抱怨鄰居的狗太吵害我睡不著,那隻狗在任何時間到底有沒有發出叫聲我也可以十猜十中啊

irischennet wrote:
因為平時坐在書桌前上網時,都用有線網路,只有去客廳才會用無線。...(恕刪)

用有線時把天線拔掉,用無線時把天線裝上。
因為線路的原因,沒法拉到客廳...

而EMF對人體可能的影響:
...
short-term, immediate health effects such as stimulation of peripheral nerves and muscles, shocks and burns caused by touching conducting objects, and elevated tissue temperatures resulting from absorption of energy during exposure to EMF”
ICNIRP Guidelines, April 1998, v.74-4, p.496

另外,關於手機和Wifi的影響性與相關度,摘要於下:http://www.powerwatch.org.uk/rf/wifi.asp

Mobile Telecommunication systems (CDMA, GSM and 3G) are both closer in frequency and are also digitally pulsed information carrying signals - these are sufficiently close to WiFi that the research into phones and their base stations may be applicable to exposure from WiFi.
(簡譯:手機訊號與wifi的訊號與頻率是相近的,因此相關的研究也許可以適用於wifi)


Firstly, typical exposure from a phone in use is likely to be far higher than from a typical WiFi laptop or access point due to the different in proximity to the device in question. So whilst, again, there is research showing that there may be a risk[2][3], this may not be relevant.

However, signal strength from a mobile phone base station where it reaches the ground (approximately 70 to 100 metres from the base station) is typically between 0.5 and 1.5 V/m, exactly the same as we measured in a WiFi classroom in a school in Norwich, and the same as found in the above calculations, and seems therefore to be very relevant. A quick survey of the literature looking very specifically into mobile phone base station epidemiology finds some statistically significant health effects[4][5][6][7][8][9][10][11][12]. Many of these are summarised, with helpful graphs, etc, in our library article "Radiofrequency EMFs and health risks". There is, in fact, very little research looking at base stations that has failed to find an effect. Also interesting is that many of the effects in the papers above (non-cancer effects) are those being reported in the anecdotal evidence from WiFi exposure.
(已有研究顯示基地台對健康會造成影響,而基地台的訊號強度等同於wifi 教室內的強度。)

In essence then, there is sufficient evidence to warrant some degree of precaution regarding WiFi until research has been done very specifically into its effects. With dLAN systems and ordinary CAT5/6 wired networks offering better stability, bandwidth and security, there is simply no need for most homes, organisations and schools to switch to wireless networks, apart from the savings of the slight inconvenience in cables.
(在有更進一步對Wifi的研究之前,對Wifi採取預防措施是有足夠證據的)

你可以編一頂安全帽式的法拉第籠,再去申請專利看看,量產的話說不定會大賣喔~~另外有法拉第籠功能的手機保護套應該也可以變成熱門商品

irischennet wrote:
很認真地請問一下大家...3) 另外有人說,法拉第籠(Faraday cage)可以阻擋,所以我是要去買銅線自己來編一個嗎?(恕刪)
回覆網友:

1) AP不能關,因為在書房要使用有線上網,所以插頭也不能拔。
2) 拆天線的話,訊號變弱,客廳就無法使用。
3) 天線轉個方向已經試過,無用。
4) 再買一台有開關的AP,看來是最快解決方式。不過我還是想問問有沒其他方法~
5) 要證明你是不是真的有被影響那也很簡單嘛,找你家人用布矇住你的眼睛,隨機開關你的wifi AP,然後讓你猜你的wifi AP目前到底是屬於開還關的狀態,要求不多,你能猜十次中十次不就證明你真的是因為它才感到不適的了?
--> 已經試過了手機有非常清楚的影響,通話超過半分鐘-->頭痛,手機移開-->頭不痛了。

不過Wifi對人體有沒有害,不在本文討論範圍之內,謝謝!

文章分享
評分
評分
複製連結
請輸入您要前往的頁數(1 ~ 21)

今日熱門文章 網友點擊推薦!