Qualcomm: Offers Strong Value Buy Opportunity On Current Pullback
已知的 QCOM 毛利60.65% 營益率31.24% 年營收成長率9% PSR=4.78
聯發科 毛利49.55% 營益率23.57% 年營收成長率63% PSR=3.1
Summary
QCOM has dropped 9.2% since April. At the same time, the technology sector (XLK) has grown by 7.2%. A differential in the QCOM/XLK pair equal of 16.4%. The negativity has been primarily due to [resolvable] concerns at Qualcomm's royalty-dependent QTL division - smartphone vendors in China allegedly under-reporting unit sales. With solid fundamentals (clean balance sheet, $32 billion cash, market growth, healthy ROE) and China issues likely priced in, QCOM presents a solid value opportunity to buy into the pullback. Here's an interesting insight: In December 2009, another tech company called Apple (NASDAQ:AAPL) was trading at 22x net earnings. Today it trades at around 16x earnings. While P/E is by no means the ideal standard for measuring value, it is fair to say if Apple traded at a P/E ratio of 22 at some point in the last 5 years, there is every chance it would do so again in the future - a reasonable justification for significant upside in Apple stock longer term. Interestingly, at 22x earnings Apple should be trading at $140.
Looking at similar stats for QCOM, in the same month/year, QCOM was trading at an incredible 49x net earnings. Currently, like AAPL, it trades at a more sobering 16x earnings. Similar multiples can be found across all key value ratio's (such as price/book, price/free-cash-flow, etc), providing strong value and longer term upside for Qualcomm.
Focusing on the most recent fundamental screen data, there is nothing unfavorable to write here - all metrics remained robust in the last quarter. Sales were up 9% (YoY), net earnings up an impressive 41.6% in the same period, operating ROE grew steadily from 18.86% to 20.45%, gross margin remained consistent at around 60%, while operating margin improved from 29.39% to 31.24%. A clean balance sheet continues to exhibit virtually zero debt. Moreover, cash-and-equivalents accounted for over $32 billion (equating to approximately $19/share).
(click to enlarge) QCOM - Qualcomm Fundamental Stock Screener Data
So, all things being equal, the 16.4% post-April negative spread between QCOM and the sector (NYSEARCA:XLK), has been the price paid for the elephant-in-the-room - the QTL wireless division (which relies on royalties, and forms a slice of overall revenue) vs China allegedly under-reporting royalty-based unit sales. If this has been priced in, as the negative spread implies, what remains is a continuing solid business with compelling value and growth fundamentals (and no debt) in a global market where China is one part (albeit a crucial part) of the overall growth picture.
While the China royalty-issues may require (as these situations always do) men/women skilled in the fine art of diplomacy - it is important to briefly review Qualcomm's business model. The company invents, develops, and patents 3G and 4G innovations. The company then licenses this knowledge to other businesses allowing them to manufacture 3G/4G parts for devices, thus effectively freeing Qualcomm to continue developing and licensing future innovations. It works. Brilliantly. Additionally, the companies that use Qualcomm's intellectual property (in China I believe there are around 90, although I do not have verification on this) are then able to compete in this global industry. In return, Qualcomm rightfully earns a royalty for the IP...
Realize then that - focusing on the bigger picture - China would not be able to participate in the 3G/4G industry without Qualcomm. One does need the other - and what is being played out is more than likely political arrogance versus reasonable resolve.
As it stands, China may be playing its hand in trying to negotiate some kind of special fee structure relating to the royalties that are due to Qualcomm, on the premise of blanket political 'anti-competitiveness' bias. In which case, Qualcomm could afford it (recall current cash & equivalents) as a one-off charge, and probably write this off as the price to pay for a more sustainable (albeit lower margin) China growth. Fines of around $1 Billion have been rumored, although it is anyone's guess. Nevertheless, no matter which way one looks at this, the fact is China needs 4G (and 3G) to stay in good stead globally, so there has to come a point where - from a somewhat optimistic standpoint (we have to make a reasoned opinion, albeit subjective) - it is in the best interests of both parties to resolve these issues. Soon.
As for the overall business structure and global markets - well I don't think any investor who knows the company could argue against Qualcomm knowing it's product and business. China is crucial to growth, but there is also, the rest of the planet to continue to serve - all unanimously advancing from 3G to 4G and beyond - and Qualcomm is, as has always been - at the cutting edge of this twenty-first century growth. It comes down to putting trust in Qualcomm management which has done a proven job steering this ship and winning meaningful market share by focus and innovation in its core fields of expertise.
While the share price may never reach the heady heights of 2009 where it traded at 49x earnings, or even 25x earnings in the not too distant past (March 2012), there is strong argument in favor of significant upside in the stock from here. The China scenario is most likely priced in (note the 16.4% spread between QCOM/XLK), and coming to an agreement out there will be the catalyst closing that 16% gap (a bonus). All other things remaining equal, I believe the stock price will continue to grow from here, presenting a timely opportunity to buy into the recent pullback.