HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asus_routers
http://www.dd-wrt.com/wiki/index.php/Supported_Devices#Asus
http://code.google.com/p/wl500g/wiki/Devices
http://www.wikidevi.com/wiki/ASUS_RT-N10U
ASUS WL/RT 系列硬體規格表
無線網路硬體規格表
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

N10U規格和N12 B1/C1/D1(1290)/HP(1490)相同皆為Broadcom BCM5357@300Mhz,NAT效能應相同

cat /proc/cpuinfo

300Mhz
system type : Broadcom BCM5357 chip rev 1 pkg 8
processor : 0
cpu model : MIPS 74K V4.9
BogoMIPS : 149.91
cpu MHz : 300
wait instruction : no
microsecond timers : yes
tlb_entries : 64
extra interrupt vector : no
hardware watchpoint : yes
ASEs implemented : mips16 dsp
shadow register sets : 1
VCED exceptions : not available
VCEI exceptions : not available

354Mhz

system type : Broadcom BCM5357 chip rev 1 pkg 8
processor : 0
cpu model : MIPS 74K V4.9
BogoMIPS : 179.81
cpu MHz : 360
wait instruction : no
microsecond timers : yes
tlb_entries : 64
extra interrupt vector : no
hardware watchpoint : yes
ASEs implemented : mips16 dsp
shadow register sets : 1
VCED exceptions : not available
VCEI exceptions : not available

dmesg

CPU: BCM5357 rev 1 pkg 8 at 360 MHz
Using 180.000 MHz high precision timer.

nvram show | grep clkfreq

clkfreq=354,177,88

480Mhz
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

CPU: BCM5357 rev 1 pkg 8 at 480 MHz
Using 240.000 MHz high precision timer.

HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

500Mhz
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

CPU: BCM5357 rev 1 pkg 8 at 500 MHz
Using 250.000 MHz high precision timer.

HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

530Mhz
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

CPU: BCM5357 rev 1 pkg 8 at 530 MHz
Using 265.000 MHz high precision timer.

HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試
4天不定時BT滿載
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

533Mhz開機後1分鐘當機
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

CPU: BCM5357 rev 1 pkg 8 at 533 MHz
Using 266.500 MHz high precision timer.

HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

查溫度
wl -i eth1 phy_tempsense

67 (0x43)

uname -a

Linux RT- 2.6.22.19 #34 Fri Jan 11 16:49:34 ICT 2013 mips GNU/Linux

cat /proc/meminfo

MemTotal: 28764 kB
MemFree: 6392 kB
Buffers: 2864 kB
Cached: 8216 kB
SwapCached: 0 kB
Active: 5984 kB
Inactive: 7376 kB
HighTotal: 0 kB
HighFree: 0 kB
LowTotal: 28764 kB
LowFree: 6392 kB
SwapTotal: 0 kB
SwapFree: 0 kB
Dirty: 0 kB
Writeback: 0 kB
AnonPages: 2288 kB
Mapped: 1920 kB
Slab: 5032 kB
SReclaimable: 624 kB
SUnreclaim: 4408 kB
PageTables: 284 kB
NFS_Unstable: 0 kB
Bounce: 0 kB
WritebackTmp: 0 kB
CommitLimit: 14380 kB
Committed_AS: 5772 kB
VmallocTotal: 1015800 kB
VmallocUsed: 3572 kB
VmallocChunk: 1009696 kB

shibby20 said: ↑
cd /tmp
wget http://tomato.groov.pl/download/Exp/robocfg
chmod +x robocfg
/tmp/robocfg show

網路線在N10U上的LAN1,但卻顯示在Port4
Switch: enabled
Port 0: 100FD enabled stp: none vlan: 1 mac: 00:00:00:00:00:00
Port 1: DOWN enabled stp: none vlan: 0 mac: 00:00:00:00:00:00
Port 2: DOWN enabled stp: none vlan: 0 mac: 00:00:00:00:00:00
Port 3: DOWN enabled stp: none vlan: 0 mac: 00:00:00:00:00:00
Port 4: 100FD enabled stp: none vlan: 0 mac: 00:00:00:00:00:00
Port 5: 100FD enabled stp: none vlan: 1 mac: 00:00:00:00:00:00
VLANs: BCM5325/535x enabled mac_check mac_hash
0: vlan0: 1 2 3 4 5t
1: vlan1: 0 5t

nvram show | grep vlan
nvram show | grep eth
nvram show | grep board
free

cat /proc/sys/net/ipv4/netfilter/ip_conntrack_fastnat

busybox
cat /proc/version
ps
ls /bin
ls /sbin
ls /usr/bin
ls /usr/sbin
wlscan

pwd
ls
cat /proc/uptime
cat /proc/loadavg
cat /proc/filesystems
cat /proc/crypto


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tomato_(firmware)#Feature_comparison

Toastman
http://toastmanfirmware.yolasite.com/

Shibby
http://tomato.groov.pl/
http://openlinksys.info/forum/viewthread.php?thread_id=11624

DualWAN
http://www.dualwan.cn/

Tomato RAF
http://www.router.tw/

N10U搭配Shibby最新105版本NAT效能無法跑滿100M Line Rate,僅適合80M以下網路使用

shibby20 said: ↑
BTW when you enable QoS or BW Limiter then internet speed will be ~50Mbps (100% usage of CPU).


BCM5357的能耐就這樣?現在市面上還在賣的分享器竟然真的有跑不到100M Line Rate的,超頻上去不知有沒有救...

http://www.dd-wrt.com/wiki/index.php/Overclocking_BCM_47xx_CPU's
http://tomatousb.org/tut:over-clocking-asus-rt-n16

http://www.linksysinfo.org/index.php?threads/vickteks-raf1-28-8655-mipsr2-k26-on-asus-rt-n16-what-cpu-speed-to-choose.33490/#post-164828
Toastman said: ↑
It is sufficient to just specify the CPU frequency and leave the other two figures (memory clock and backplane) to be set by the router, which will set them at f/2 and f/4.


Toastman版本支援頻率調整
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

小超試試(354,177,88)
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

有看到480,160,801,2,但Toastman版本WebUI只有480,240,120

N10U記憶體ESMT M13S2561616A-5T datasheet DDR400
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

預設:(300,150,75)
目前穩定:(480,160,80),(500,160,80),(530,160,80)
BT測試會當機:(480,200,100),(480,190,95),(480,180,90),(480,170,85)
nvram set clkfreq=480,160,80
nvram commit
reboot

試過(500,200,100)了,開機只有5秒可以ping的通,關電源幾分鐘後可以ping通的時間變長了(應是過熱+SoC記憶體控制器受不了200Mhz),趕快SSH進去更改頻率,reboot

(500,160,80)可開機,穩定度和CPU Load 100%溫度與(480,160,80)差不多

HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

RT-N15U: BCM5357 @ 500MHz
HG320 BCM5357 @ 533MHz
ZTE H218N V1 BCM5357 @ 533MHz
Netgear WNR3500L v2: BCM5357 @ 480MHz
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

Hard Reset Or 30/30/30
各分享器測試(含超頻)


測試方法
http://www.dualwan.cn/index.php/download/category/52-tomato-dualwan
cd /tmp

wget http://www.dualwan.cn/downloads/tools/openwrt_cpu_bench

chmod +x openwrt_cpu_bench

./openwrt_cpu_bench



N10U @ (500,160,80)

tomato-K26USB-1.28.0501.2MIPSR2Toastman-RT-N-VLAN-VPN.trx(2013/1/11)

This is CPU and memory benchmark for OpenWRT v0.6. This will then take some time... (typically 30-60 seconds on a 200MHz computer)
Overhead for getting time: 28us
Time to run memory bench: 2.96[secs]
Time to run computation of pi (2400 digits, 10 times): 6.08[secs]
Time to run computation of e (9009 digits): 5.29[secs]
Time to run float bench: 2.55[secs]
Total time: 16.9s

You can copy/paste the following line in the wiki table at: http://wiki.openwrt.org/HardwarePerformance
|| 2013-02-02 || ''Author'' || 3.0s || 6.1s || 5.3s || 2.6s || v0.6 || ''OS'' || ''DeviceModel'' || ''CPU model'' || ''CPU Frequency'' || ''LinkToHwPage'' ||

能關的全關剩Upnp,測試時把對外連線中斷
tomato-K26USB-1.28.0501.2MIPSR2Toastman-RT-N-VLAN-VPN.trx(2013/1/11)

This is CPU and memory benchmark for OpenWRT v0.6. This will then take some time... (typically 30-60 seconds on a 200MHz computer)
Overhead for getting time: 28us
Time to run memory bench: 2.93[secs]
Time to run computation of pi (2400 digits, 10 times): 5.93[secs]
Time to run computation of e (9009 digits): 5.12[secs]
Time to run float bench: 2.46[secs]
Total time: 16.4s

You can copy/paste the following line in the wiki table at: http://wiki.openwrt.org/HardwarePerformance
|| 2013-02-02 || ''Author'' || 2.9s || 5.9s || 5.1s || 2.5s || v0.6 || ''OS'' || ''DeviceModel'' || ''CPU model'' || ''CPU Frequency'' || ''LinkToHwPage'' ||


N10U @ (530,160,80)

能關的全關剩Upnp,測試時把對外連線中斷
tomato-K26USB-1.28.0501.2MIPSR2Toastman-RT-N-VLAN-VPN.trx(2013/1/11)

This is CPU and memory benchmark for OpenWRT v0.6. This will then take some time... (typically 30-60 seconds on a 200MHz computer)
Overhead for getting time: 26us
Time to run memory bench: 2.75[secs]
Time to run computation of pi (2400 digits, 10 times): 5.59[secs]
Time to run computation of e (9009 digits): 4.85[secs]
Time to run float bench: 2.28[secs]
Total time: 15.5s

You can copy/paste the following line in the wiki table at: http://wiki.openwrt.org/HardwarePerformance
|| 2013-02-03 || ''Author'' || 2.7s || 5.6s || 4.9s || 2.3s || v0.6 || ''OS'' || ''DeviceModel'' || ''CPU model'' || ''CPU Frequency'' || ''LinkToHwPage'' ||


塞爾維亞網站蒐集的數據
Сравнение производительности процессоров роутеров
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

Router CPU and memory benchmark

N10U @ 300Mhz NAT效能實測


tomato-K26USB-1.28.RT-N5x-MIPSR2-105-BT-VPN

Web Monitor,Syslog,Bandwidth Monitoring,IP Traffic Monitoring,UPnP,Core USB Support,File Sharing,PPTP Server開啟
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試


UPnP,Core USB Support,File Sharing,PPTP Server開啟
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試


WebUI能關的全關只剩UPnP
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試


TP-Link 741ND 可跑滿100M Line Rate,當初買690,N10U買699
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

[已知問題]N10U+tomato無線網路使用N時FTP速度僅1.3Mbps(WAN為PPPoE)


http://digiland.tw/viewtopic.php?pid=11597#p11597
Shibby 105(2013/1/23)

Dr.SPEED 走FTP Protocol
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

tomato-K26USB-1.28.RT-N5x-MIPSR2-106-VPN(2013/2/19)
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

Toastman

tomato-K26USB-1.28.0501.2MIPSR2Toastman-RT-N-VLAN-VPN.trx(2013/1/11)

HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試




2013/2/7 UpDate

WAN為DHCP時FTP速率正常

kbro 12M/3M
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

PPPoE-Relay


PPPoE-Relay著重在記憶體的速率,(CPU,RAM,backplane)

(480,160,80)在PPPoE-Relay的表現上比(354,177,88)差

Shibby的版本需使用tomato-K26USB-1.28.RT-N5x-MIPSR2-105-VPN,Big-VPN剩餘空間不足,BT-VPN連JFFS選項都沒有
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

1. mkdir -p /tmp/test; cd /tmp/test

2. wget http://kamikaze.openwrt.org/8.09.2/brcm-2.4/packages/rp-pppoe-relay_3.10-1_mipsel.ipk

3. tar xzf rp-pppoe-relay_3.10-1_mipsel.ipk

4. tar xzf data.tar.gz

5. cp usr/sbin/pppoe-relay /jffs

6. cd /; rm -rf /tmp/test

7. /jffs/pppoe-relay -S vlan1 -C br0

8.
Administration=>Scripts=>Init
sleep 10 && /jffs/pppoe-relay -S vlan1 -C br0
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

cd /jffs/
mkdir opt
ls -l
df -h


HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

Toastman

HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

[300Mhz]無線網路PPPOE-relay效能僅35M Line Rate

HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

[354Mhz]無線網路PPPOE-relay效能達54M Line Rate

HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

[300Mhz]有線網路PPPOE-relay效能僅42M Line Rate

HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

P872H NAT效能只有3M,但透過PPPOE-relay撥上去卻可達50M,同樣是PPPOE-relay卻有完全不同的效能?

http://www.mobile01.com/topicdetail.php?f=110&t=2918200&p=3#26
yungyao wrote:
而華碩原廠韌體本來就有pppoe relay了阿
會用這功能 其實是要換ip 總不能要換個ip 我就要rt-n16重啟一次吧
不管是第3方韌體 或是 華碩原廠韌體 電腦透過rt-n16 pppoe 出去只有60幾m


BT測試


連線數僅306
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試
480Mhz CPU Load滿載(不管任何狀況,流量只要達50M就是如此,20M約50%)
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

USB


可抓到1.5TB隨身硬碟
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

VLAN


tomato上面的Port4=實際上的LAN1

無線功率


RT-N10U
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試
RT-N10U B
HiNet 100M/100M+ASUS RT-N10U+Tomato Shibby 105 簡單測試

兩者的差距真的只有換殼而已


ASUS原廠韌體?不穩定的韌體連測的價值都沒有....
文章關鍵字
測原廠韌體多少有些用

如果原廠韌體能上,TOMATO才有能上的機會

要是原廠韌體不能上,TOMATO大概就沒機會了

要求 rt-n10u 都要跑滿 100M,

買 rt-n16 不就.....

有一個外國測試網站,rt-n16 可以達到 11X M!

當然還有其他幾款,就 rt-n16最便宜了。

搜尋m01,上個月才在討論!


kysf wrote:
http://en....(恕刪)
kysf兄有測試硬體NAT 的加速嗎?

好像shibby在10x版 firmware以後有提供,要去開啟。不過我自己沒試過。

ASUS官版現在算穩定了吧?只是我嫌它設定管理頁跑太慢不喜歡。
un3354 wrote:
要求 rt-n10u 都要跑滿 100M,

買 rt-n16 不就.....

TP-Link 741ND 可跑滿100M Line Rate

相同價格帶的產品一個做得到一個做不到就這麼簡單

741ND還是2010年買的

與N10U用相同晶片的有N12 B1/C1/D1(1290)/HP(1490)

1490的價位都不能要求跑滿100M Line Rate的話........頗

對了,這是N10U附的超短網路線(只有4條)
If you do not go within, you go without.
Paneb wrote:
kysf兄有測試硬體NAT 的加速嗎?

好像shibby在10x版 firmware以後有提供,要去開啟。不過我自己沒試過。

http://www.mobile01.com/topicdetail.php?f=110&t=3132310#41059280
快意奔馳 wrote:
我的 RT-N16 在開啟CTF之後 (Shibby MIPSR2-093 AIO)
WIFI訊號容易有斷線的情況發生,有線的部份沒事
關閉CTF試了一天,WIFI沒斷線了

會試試...不知會有多大的成長且其他影響未知
Paneb wrote:
ASUS官版現在算穩定了吧?只是我嫌它設定管理頁跑太慢不喜歡。

http://digiland.tw/viewtopic.php?id=2189

http://www.mobile01.com/topicdetail.php?f=110&t=3184402#3
eddiepi wrote:
無線爛就算了
現在接有線的跑BT還不到三千個session就當機沒反應
是RT-N12HP品質太爛?

http://www.mobile01.com/topicdetail.php?f=110&t=3173331&p=3#41446412
wenchenb wrote:
我刷官方最新韌體,好像從來沒有uptime超過24hr .......
一個禮拜後受不了就刷回shibby了 :|

http://www.mobile01.com/topicdetail.php?f=110&t=3187939
ciryl3802 wrote:
話說入手這台N12HP也是店員推薦的

但帶回家之後才真的是災難的開始

先說說我的問題好了

常常上網上到突然無法連線FB,或者連進去了,圖片卻都開不出來

YOUTOBE、奇摩也常常會有這種問題,LINE也會突然斷線
gravady wrote:
今天入手N12hp 結果遇到一模一樣的問題
非常困擾!
不曉得板大解決了沒有?

http://www.mobile01.com/topicdetail.php?f=110&t=3191937
q71232 wrote:
請問使用RT-N66U的朋友,有無線不穩定的問題嗎?
使用官方韌體!
然後VPN問題!
麻煩個位大大幫幫!
If you do not go within, you go without.
kysf wrote:
TP-Link 741ND 可跑滿100M Line Rate
相同價格帶的產品一個做得到一個做不到就這麼簡單
741ND還是2010年買的
與N10U用相同晶片的有N12 B1/C1/D1(1290)/HP(1490)
1490的價位都不能要求跑滿100M Line Rate的話........頗
對了,這是N10U附的超短網路線(只有4條)...(恕刪)

不能這樣比啦....
規格上就不一樣了,雖然價格差不多

RT-N10U H.W. rev - Broadcom BCM5357@300
RT-N12 H.W. rev - Broadcom BCM4716@300
RT-N12 H.W. rev B1 Broadcom BCM5357@300
RT-N12 H.W. rev C Broadcom BCM5357@300

TP-Link WR741N(D) H.W. rev 1.x, 2.x Atheros AR7240@400
TP-Link WR741ND H.W. rev 4.x Atheros AR9331@400


目前還是有一堆還跑不滿100M的滿街跑....

針對未來光纖網路請參考以下網站測試數據
如果設備考慮未來擴充性....建議選購WAN<=>LAN頻寬超過100M的分享器
>>http://www.smallnetbuilder.com/lanwan/router-charts/view
只出得起香蕉的公司自然只能請到猴子! 客戶爛不是廠商爛! 老是下訂單給這種爛廠商,不就正代表了其實是你們爛! 明知道廠商爛還一而再再而三下訂單給他們?

t96320147 wrote:
TP-Link WR741N(D) H.W. rev 1.x, 2.x Atheros AR7240@400

http://www.mobile01.com/topicdetail.php?f=110&t=2216247#28772871

DD-WRT上是顯示350Mhz
If you do not go within, you go without.

kysf wrote:
http://www.mobile01.com/topicdetail.php?f=110&t=2216247#28772871
DD-WRT上是顯示350Mhz...(恕刪)

這我不清楚....

Spec是直接查詢DD-WRT的Supported Devices
TP-Link
只出得起香蕉的公司自然只能請到猴子! 客戶爛不是廠商爛! 老是下訂單給這種爛廠商,不就正代表了其實是你們爛! 明知道廠商爛還一而再再而三下訂單給他們?
請教大大們,
現階段RT-N10U與RT-N12 D1比較,哪個較值得入手?
速度上限不一樣,價格也差了不少...
先謝了~
文章分享
評分
評分
複製連結

今日熱門文章 網友點擊推薦!