有人有實際用過Seagate 100GB/2.5吋/7200轉 HDD for IDE 嗎?

請問大大們有沒有實際用過這顆硬碟?
可否提供一下這台的使用心得?
我用過7200轉160G的;

速度上我認為比不上7K100(我也用過);但是己經比5400轉的快多了。

PS 我是個懶人;別問我比較數據。

從加拿大向你問好。
i have seagate on my Powerbook. For some reason, i think it is not a reliable HD. I had to replace it twice in 2 years. (under AppleCare Warranty)

the 3rd time when the HD died, Apple replace it with Hitachi 7K100. i think it is better.

Seagate is faster in read/write single big file (for ex, 1G Video file) Hitachi is faster in writing many smaller files, (for ex, boot up, or copy 1000 pictures at 1MB each)

noise it about the same, (at least i don't find any difference in my powerbook)

unless u Have to use 7200 rpm drive. i think the newer 160G 5400rpm is a better choice. (or 250G 5400 rpm HD)

on the newer 160 5400rpm hd, the speed is almost the same as old 7200rpm 100G. however, use about 2/3 of the power only, and you get a bigger HD for the same price.

and btw, Hitachi 5K160 is a better choice than Seagate 5400.2 160G in IDE. (if you go SATA, it's the other way around)
我用的是5400.3系列中的160g版本~!性能不錯,就是溫度有點高~!買之前有心理準備哦~!
感謝大大們的回應...
有其中一位大大說有用過它的160GB..7200轉的..
可是IDE不是只出到100GB嗎..還是我弄錯了?
也感謝Antus 的詳細解說..
看完之後,我忽然發現,原來我的破爛英文能力至少還能閱讀這篇文章..哈哈~
不過感覺大大們對這顆硬碟的評價不是很高..
但是,我爬文後看到的是說H牌的會有雜音且溫度比較高,不過效能的確比S牌的好..
不知道是否真是如此...
這顆S牌的硬碟不知道有沒有使用過的大大覺得它不錯的?可否也分享一下使用經驗?
我用的是S牌7200轉80G的~~個人認為爽度還是很明顯~~

這顆硬碟是中古品~~我又狂操了兩年 (開機23H/DAY~半數是BT)

跟手上另一台NB全新5400轉的比起來還是毫不遜色

運轉幾乎無聲~~有用散熱墊BT 12小時溫度大約40~43

有次散熱墊忘了插上USB孔~~起床一看56度

不過應該不全是硬碟的溫度~~ASUS是出了名的熱阿

附上HDtune的測試圖你參考看看嚕


clarklin wrote:
感謝大大們的回應.....(恕刪)


you are welcome.

usually, on IDE, Hitachi's performance is better than Seagate. (the difference is quite big, around 20% faster)

HD technology change so fast, there is really no reason to buy last generation 7200rpm when the newer 5400rpm is faster and use less power.
所以您認為就IDE硬碟來講 7k100的整體表現會比Seagate Momentus 7200.1好囉?

還是說新款的 Momentus 5400.3 的表現就很接近上述兩顆硬碟?

小弟用的NB是Toshiba M50,搭配的是Toshiba 5400轉的IDE硬碟

用HD Tune 2.54測試的結果如下:

溫度49度

Transfer Rate Mini 4.2 MB/sec Max 30.9 MB/sec Average 26.6 MB/sec

Access Time 17.1 ms Burst Rate 68.2 MB/sec

想升級成Hitachi 7k80 or Seagate Momentus 7200.1

貨源方面可能上pchome買,建國商場幾乎都沒有現貨

價錢方面還算公道 Hitachi 7k80 (nt2999) Seagate Momentus 7200.1 (nt3079)

想請教有經驗的版友,在效能上會有多少助益?Hitachi or Seagate?

還是M50已經沒有升級的必要性了? M50 是 PM1.6G 1G ram
daiyang wrote:
所以您認為就IDE硬...(恕刪)


yes, on IDE, Hitachi 7K100 is faster than Seagate 7200.1 100G IDE. the difference is about 5-10%
especially the IDE Seagate died on me twice in my PowerBook, i think 7K100 is a better choice between the 2.

when compare between 7K100, 5400.3 160G, and 5K160 160G.
If you are talking about absolute speed, 7K100 is still the fastest between these 3, but the difference is small, maybe like 5% (depends on application) Personally, if the performance and price so close, i will take bigger drive. (both about the same price, ie, 7k100 vs. 5k160)

160G in reality has double the capacity of 100G. why? if system software takes 30G, you have "usable" space of 130G to 70G.

on ur M50, i think upgrade is not necessary if you want speed. if you want space, get the biggest one u can find on IDE. (currently 5k160 or WD 250G 5400rpm)
就上面 fr113359 的數據圖來看好像跟我的5400轉差異不大

如果只是單就容量的issue 我還有外接的3.5吋硬碟 所以我要的是磁碟效能

唉.....看起來還是砍掉重練比較快..........M50的極限阿

感謝Antus的經驗分享
文章分享
評分
評分
複製連結

今日熱門文章 網友點擊推薦!